PPI - Radically Pragmatic
  • Donate
Skip to content
  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Locations
    • Careers
  • People
  • Projects
  • Our Work
  • Events
  • Donate

Our Work

Child Payments and a VAT Are Fairer than the So-Called “Fair Tax”

  • June 29, 2023
  • Nick Buffie
Download PDF

INTRODUCTION

Earlier this year, 31 House Republicans released a proposal to replace virtually all federal taxes with a 30% national sales tax. As other analysts have noted, a sales tax would be easy for companies to dodge and difficult for the government to enforce — meaning that to avoid revenue losses, the proposal would require a significantly higher tax rate, possibly as high as 60%.

The bill has also been criticized for being regressive. In tax terminology, a tax is “regressive” if it takes a higher share of income from the poor than from the rich; “flat” or “proportional” if it takes the same share of income from everybody; and “progressive” if it takes a higher share from the rich than from the poor.

The Republicans’ overall bill is certainly regressive and should be rejected on that account. But its core idea — taxing consumption rather than income — is not inherently regressive if properly designed. Much public commentary has mistakenly concluded that a national sales tax would fall predominantly on low-income Americans. But as this analysis demonstrates, taxes on spending fall on everyone roughly equally, and certain elements of the Fair Tax — such as its universal child payments — are actually progressive. While the Fair Tax ought to be rejected due to its regressive tax cuts and poor enforceability, two elements of it are worth keeping: its flat per-child cash payments and its emphasis on taxing spending rather than saving.

Read the full report.

Related Work

Budget Breakdown  |  May 22, 2025

House Republicans Pass ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ Despite Several Big Red Flags

  • Ben Ritz Alex Kilander
Op-Ed  |  May 22, 2025

Ritz for Forbes: House Republicans Pass ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ Despite Big Red Flags

  • Ben Ritz
Podcast  |  May 21, 2025

Ritz on the Concord Coalition’s Facing the Future Podcast: Is Trump Repeating Biden’s Mistakes?

  • Ben Ritz
In the News  |  May 20, 2025

Ritz on SiriusXM POTUS: The Briefing

  • Ben Ritz
Press Release  |  May 16, 2025

Loss of AAA Rating for U.S. Credit Underscores Grave Consequences of Trump’s Budget-Busting Bill

  • Ben Ritz
Blog  |  May 16, 2025

The Data Center Boom

  • Michael Mandel
  • Never miss an update:

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
PPI Logo
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Donate
  • Careers
  • © 2025 Progressive Policy Institute. All Rights Reserved.
  • |
  • Privacy Policy
  • |
  • Privacy Settings