PPI - Radically Pragmatic
  • Donate
Skip to content
  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Locations
    • Careers
  • People
  • Projects
  • Our Work
  • Events
  • Donate

Our Work

Rotherham for US News, “Challenge Students, Don’t Shield Them”

  • July 20, 2017
  • Andrew J. Rotherham

Tap Tapley, the legendary Outward Bound instructor, is said to have described the crux of the experiential outdoor experiential learning school’s approach as “inducing anxiety and then releasing it in a constructive manner.”

And for a half century, Outward Bound courses have done just that – putting students in challenging and uncomfortable situations with real and immediate consequences. Students find themselves climbing mountains, paddling rivers, exploring remote canyons, traveling in the wilderness in winter conditions or sailing. Students learn skills to survive and thrive in these settings. But more importantly they learn about themselves; compassion and empathy for others; their capabilities; and tenacity and resiliency in pursuit of challenging goals.

But this model is pretty much the exact opposite of the scene at many residential colleges today, especially our most elite ones. Instead of challenge, much of the debate on college campuses today turns on ideas about intellectually “safe” spaces, where students don’t have to encounter ideas that make them uncomfortable or engage with those with whom they disagree.

Just last week, Harvard University, a school regarded as a breadbasket of future American leaders, decided that free association, allowing its students to decide what clubs they want to join, threatened its ideas about inclusivity. (Yes, obviously richly ironic, given what it takes to get into Harvard in the first place.) Meanwhile, the college curriculum has at many schools become basically an a la carte experience, where students can gravitate toward courses that reinforce rather than challenge their worldview.

Read more at US News.

Related Work

Op-Ed  |  July 24, 2026

Canter and Manno for Thomas Fordham Institute: Good programs aren’t enough: States need a work-based learning strategy

  • Rachel Canter Bruno Manno
Blog  |  July 23, 2026

Canter on Radically Pragmatic Substack: How Mississippi Almost Abandoned Its Education Reforms

  • Rachel Canter
Trade Fact  |  July 15, 2026

America’s ‘industrial’ working class has shrunk by about a million since 2016

  • Ed Gresser
Press Release  |  July 14, 2026

Work-Based Learning Requires Support from Policymakers, Industry, PPI Highlights in New Report

  • Rachel Canter Bruno Manno
Publication  |  July 14, 2026

A Practical Guide to Work-Based Learning: Lessons from Six Programs at the Cutting-Edge of Career Education

  • Rachel Canter Bruno Manno
Op-Ed  |  July 7, 2026

Manno for Real Clear Education: School Absences Aren’t Created Equal: A Smarter Way to Fight Chronic Absenteeism

  • Bruno Manno
  • Never miss an update:

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
PPI Logo
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Donate
  • Careers
  • © 2026 Progressive Policy Institute. All Rights Reserved.
  • |
  • Privacy Policy
  • |
  • Privacy Settings