The proposed merger of Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern (“UP-NS”) would create a coast-to-coast railroad monopoly controlling almost 40% of U.S. track, and 45% of U.S. rail freight by revenue, according to a protest filed today with the Surface Transportation Board (STB) by the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI).
Filed by Diana Moss, Vice President and Director of Competition Policy at PPI, the protest examines how creating a transcontinental U.S. railroad monopoly will eliminate essential rail competition that harms freight shippers and, ultimately, American consumers. PPI’s protest concludes that the merger is “too big to fix” and urges the Board to deny the application.
The deal would cap decades of consolidation that has shrunk the number of Class I railroads from 63 in 1976 to six today. A broad coalition of railroads and shippers already opposes the UP-NS merger. PPI’s protest warns that higher freight rates would be passed on to millions of consumers for everything from agriculture, to energy, and construction commodities that move by rail, worsening one of the most severe cost-of-living crises in U.S. history.
But the conditions UP-NS offers would not restore the competition the merger eliminates, the protest argues. For example, the remedies do not eliminate UP-NS’s ability and incentive to disadvantage competing railroads. Pricing protections would apply to a tiny percentage of shipments potentially affected by the merger. Moreover, merger fixes depend on smaller market participants to report violations, but who are reluctant to do so because they fear retaliation.
“A coast-to-coast rail monopoly is the last thing American families need in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis,” said Moss. “When freight rates go up, so do prices for food, fuel, building materials, and everyday goods that move by rail. No set of temporary, hard-to-enforce conditions can undo that kind of market power. This deal is too big to fix, and the Board should deny it.”
The protest finds:
Shippers at major interchange points that already have little choice in independent railroads would lose even more choice, with many becoming “captive” to UP-NS.
A transcontinental UP-NS would have both the ability and the incentive to squeeze out rival railroads by manipulating gateway and interchange access, raising fees, or degrading service on shipments that rely partly on a competitor’s network.
UP has already signaled its pricing power. Its CEO warned in March 2026 that he would probably raise rates by “three or four extra percent” on customers who opposed the merger “to teach [them] a lesson.”
UP contradicts its own past position. In the 2023 Canadian Pacific-Kansas City Southern merger, it urged the Board to weigh the risk that a merged railroad would shut out rivals, a concern the Board accepted. Now that its own deal is under review, UP argues that such foreclosure is impossible in the rail industry.
Behavioral conditions have a poor track record. The Justice Department relied on similar “access” commitments in the Live Nation-Ticketmaster merger, which the company repeatedly violated before the department sued to break it up.
The protest urges the Board to reject the applicants’ claim that end-to-end rail mergers pose no risk of foreclosing competition, reject behavioral fixes, and find that the merger is not in the public interest. In a country as large and geographically diverse as the United States, it argues, more competition in freight rail, not less, is essential to economic growth and to keeping costs down for American consumers.
Read and download the protest here.
Founded in 1989, PPI is a catalyst for policy innovation and political reform based in Washington, D.C. Its mission is to create radically pragmatic ideas for moving America beyond ideological and partisan deadlock. Find an expert and learn more about PPI by visiting progressivepolicy.org. Follow us at @PPI.
###
Media Contact: Ian O’Keefe – iokeefe@ppionline.org