Despite repeated warnings from Social Security’s trustees that the program is facing a growing financial shortfall, lawmakers seem to have reached a bipartisan consensus to kick the can down the road. If they continue procrastinating until Social Security’s trust funds near depletion in the 2030s, it will be impossible to save the program without abruptly cutting benefits for retirees or significantly reducing the lifetime incomes of young workers. Americans who rely on Social Security cannot afford to wait much longer for lawmakers to enact corrections.
Unfortunately, a new proposal that was the subject of a congressional hearing earlier this month, Social Security 2100: A Sacred Trust, moves in the wrong direction. It would worsen intergenerational inequities by providing substantial benefit increases for those becoming benefit-eligible in 2022-2026, while passing the costs to everyone else, especially young workers already getting the short end of the stick under current law. There is no justification for such discriminatory treatment. In fact, those who would receive the proposed windfall already benefit from superior treatment under current Social Security law, relative to those who would pay for it.