Marshall for The Hill: The Midterm Avalanche Reveals a New Political Geography

Nobody predicted the stunning sweep and depth of Democratic gains in last week’s midterm elections. More than a wave, it was an avalanche that revealed new contours in America’s political geography.

It’s probably time to toss those red-blue election maps we’ve become so used to since 2000. They show the main parties hunkered down behind static battle lines, with serious electoral competition confined to a dwindling number of swing states and districts.

The post-midterm map looks strikingly different. In addition to giving Democrats imposing majorities in Congress, U.S. voters in nearly every county in the country shifted in a blue direction. They won federal and state races across the upper and deep South and the broad middle from Ohio to Iowa and Kansas, enlarging the political battlefield and potentially adding a slew of new swing states.

Democrats scored big down ballot gains. They’re poised to control 30 governor’s mansions, up from 24, and have 22 trifecta wins — governors plus both legislative houses — to the Republicans’ 18.

Read more in The Hill

After Midterm Rebuke, Congress Should Take Back Tariff Power and Repeal Trump’s Decrees

WASHINGTON (November 11, 2026) — The incoming Congress can answer voters’ demand for a more affordable life by repealing President Donald Trump’s tariffs, which now cost the average American family $1,077 per year, and reclaiming the constitutional authority over tariff rates the administration bypassed through more than 50 executive decrees, according to a new report from the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI).

Authored by Ed Gresser, Vice President and Director for Trade and Global Markets at PPI, “End of an Error: The Future of Trade Policy After the Midterms” examines how the administration imposed the first general U.S. tariff increase since Herbert Hoover’s in 1930 without a vote of Congress; the impact these higher tariffs have had on American families, farmers, and businesses; and what lawmakers can do about it. It concludes that dismantling the tariff wall is, in legal terms, relatively easy, because it rests on legally flimsy decrees rather than durable law. Congress should thus focus first on restoring its own Constitutional authority over tariff rates and undoing the Trump administration’s tariff decrees, while beginning a longer-term discussion, leading into the 2028 presidential campaign, of the new policies that should replace it.

Since January 2025, the administration’s decrees have raised the trade-weighted U.S. tariff rate from 2.3% in 2024 to 11.0% this fall, and lifted tariff collections from $76 billion in 2024 to $265 billion in 2025. Public opinion has turned sharply. Opposition that ran 55% to 60% in early 2025 often reached 70% by late summer 2026, as Republicans, rural families, and Americans without college degrees soured on the policy.

But the deepest damage, the report argues, is constitutional. Article I gives Congress authority over tariffs and taxes, and even protectionist presidents like William McKinley, Warren Harding, and Hoover asked Congress to pass tariff laws rather than attempting to create their own tariff systems by fiat. The Trump administration instead repurposed decades-old statutes, including the International Emergency Economic Powers Act and Sections 122, 232, 301, and 338 of U.S. trade law, to impose tariffs by decree, issuing a new one about every two weeks. Without reform, the report warns, every future president facing congressional opposition will know he or she can do the same.

“Voters weighed the Trump tariff program in the balance and found it wanting,” said Gresser. “The new Congress doesn’t need a complicated plan to respond. It can take back its constitutional power over tariffs, repeal the decrees that are raising costs for families, farmers, and manufacturers, and start building a trade policy based on America’s real strengths instead of nostalgia for the 1890s.”

The report finds:

  • Tariffs cost American families an average of $1,077 a year, with the heaviest relative burden on low-income households, and New York Fed economists estimate that by February 2026 they had added 2.9 percentage points to goods inflation, without which goods prices would have fallen slightly
  • Industry has been hit at least as hard as consumers. Even under a broad definition, consumer goods made up just 42% of U.S. imports in 2025; the rest were inputs for builders, farmers, and manufacturers. U.S. steel prices rose from $758 per ton in January 2025 to $1,208 by midsummer 2026, nearly double prices in Europe and Japan
  • Since 2024, farm incomes have fallen 5%, and farm bankruptcies have nearly doubled, while the 2025 trade fight with China cost U.S. agriculture $20 billion in lost exports
  • Manufacturing now employs 20,000 fewer workers than in 2024, and its share of GDP has slipped from 9.8% to 9.5%
  • In California’s Central Valley, 50% tariffs on steel and tin cans helped close Del Monte’s Modesto cannery this summer, eliminating 600 jobs, voiding $500 million in peach and pear contracts, and forcing farmers to rip out 420,000 peach trees

The report recommends that Congress repair the Constitution and restore the separation of powers, use tariff policy to make things cheaper rather than more expensive, and begin a two-year process to build consensus on a new trade agenda to replace the Trump program.

First, lawmakers should require a formal vote of approval before any president can use Sections 232, 301, or 201 to impose tariffs, require a similar vote before a president withdraws from or rewrites a congressionally approved trade agreement such as the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement, and repeal outdated authorities including Sections 122 and 338. Much of this, Gresser notes, is already written into bills introduced this year by Rep. Linda Sánchez (D-Calif.) and Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.)

Second, Congress should repeal any Trump tariff decrees that survive court challenges, giving priority to those that have strained relations with Canada and Mexico and done disproportionate harm to rural America, and freeze the administration’s USMCA review until the next president takes office. Decisions on China tariffs should wait for the next administration so it can set a broader China strategy, ideally with allies. Congress should also review the permanent tariff code, which taxes cheap sneakers at 48% and leather dress shoes at 8.5%, and charges women nearly $3 billion a year by taxing their clothing at rates about 3 percentage points higher than men’s. The Pink Tariffs Study Act from Reps. Lizzie Fletcher (D-Texas) and Brittany Pettersen (D-Colo.) offers a starting point.

Third, policymakers should use the next two years to rethink the pessimistic premises behind a decade of trade policy, from the Biden White House’s “post-neoliberalism” to the Trump administration’s “national conservatism,” and build a confident agenda on American strengths, including $2.9 trillion in annual factory output, more than $1 trillion a year in research and development, and the world’s leading digital economy. The report calls this America’s “return to the world”: rebuilding ties with neighbors and allies, renewing trade preferences for developing countries, setting practical goals at the World Trade Organization, and leading on digital trade and artificial intelligence rules.

With more than 700 days left in Trump’s term, the report concludes, Congress may not be able to undo everything at once, but it can make the next two years a period of reform that restores the constitutional balance, shuts down as many bad policies as possible, and lays the groundwork for the next president.

Read and download the report here.

 

Founded in 1989, PPI is a catalyst for policy innovation and political reform based in Washington, D.C. Its mission is to create radically pragmatic ideas for moving America beyond ideological and partisan deadlock. Find an expert and learn more about PPI by visiting progressivepolicy.org. Follow us at @PPI.

###

Media Contact: Ian O’Keefe – iokeefe@ppionline.org

Ainsley in Politico: Why the Democrats’ Midterm Blowout Is Making Burnham’s Labour Nervous

[…]

Claire Ainsley, a former adviser to Starmer who works for the Progressive Policy Institute think tank on both sides of the Atlantic, told POLITICO that, despite arguments about the future direction of the Democratic Party, “what they’ve all had in common is a real focus on affordability.”

“They’ve really focused on bread-and-butter issues for everyday Americans, and clearly that’s the path to be building and hopefully winning in 2028,” she said.

Ainsley highlighted striking moves by a host of prominent Democratic politicians, including Mamdani, who has offered childcare support to New Yorkers, and New Jersey’s Mikie Sherrill — who declared “a state of emergency” on utility bills. Virginia’s Abigail Spanberger has targeted the cost of prescriptions.

“You’ve still got people who are worried here and wouldn’t necessarily say the cost of living is being relieved,” Ainsley warned. “You’ve got interest rates going up and there are lots of warning signs on our dashboard.”

[…]

Read more in Politico. 

Marshall for USA Today: The 5 Midterm Winners Democrats Should Build 2028 Around

For two years, Americans have endured the unsettling spectacle of a would-be autocrat trying to monopolize power and rule by decree. In the midterm elections, voters put an emphatic end to President Donald Trump’s wild ride on Nov. 3.

The vote was a massive repudiation of the president’s idiosyncratic governing priorities, especially his throwback tariffs and his rash decision to ignite an open-ended war with Iran. Both drove up the prices of everyday necessities, making a mockery of Trump’s campaign promise to “immediately bring prices down, starting on day one.”

Across the country, Republican candidates were dragged down by Trump’s woeful job approval – 38% – and voters’ dismal view of the economy. And their indictment of Trumpian chaos and misrule didn’t end there.

Keep reading in USA Today. 

Marshall in The Times: How Democrat James Talarico Won His Senate Race and Turned Texas Blue

[…]

Moderate Democrats will point to Talarico’s breakthrough victory in Texas as evidence that only centrist candidates can appeal to swing voters in red states. He is already viewed by some as a potential presidential candidate in 2028.

“If we’re going to be serious about winning back red states, then we have to pick candidates who are suited to the electorates,” said Will Marshall, a former ally of Bill Clinton and head of the Progressive Policy Institute, a moderate Democrat think tank. Referring to the Democratic Socialists of America, a left-wing group, he said: “The DSA types aren’t going to compete. They’re not going to win in Texas. But candidates like Talarico can.”

[…]

Keep reading in The Times.

Marshall in The Washington Sun: Experts Describe the Midterm Results in One Word

[…]

Blowback

I’m really struck by how much tonight’s GOP debacle reflects President Donald Trump’s bad decisions — on policy, on candidates and on his midterm redistricting ploy.

Voters, including many who supported him two years ago, offered an emphatic thumbs down on his signature initiatives — especially tariffs and his impulsive attack on Iran — which have made working families’ cost-of-living crisis worse. Then there’s Trump’s spectacularly bad judgment in foisting weak candidates — like Ken Paxton, Michael Whatley, Darline Graham and Vivek Ramaswamy — on his party. He sure can’t pick ’em! This enabled Democrats to pull off stunning upsets deep in the red zone and perhaps create more battleground states. Nor have the president’s imperious instructions to GOP state leaders to gerrymander their way to victory paid off. In fact, it appears that Republicans are even managing to lose races in districts redrawn to give them a supposedly insurmountable advantage.

Midterm setbacks are common, but it’s hard to think of another midterm election in which a sitting president did more to create the basic conditions for his party’s sweeping defeat. This is a catastrophe for Trump and for Republicans who have obeyed him with cultish fervor.

[…]

Continue reading in The Washington Sun.

Midterm Rout Shows Trump’s Spell Is Broken

WASHINGTON (November 4, 2026) — Will Marshall, president and founder of the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI), released the following statement on the results of Tuesday’s midterm elections, in which Democrats won control of both the House and Senate and flipped Senate seats in Republican strongholds including Texas, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Kansas:

“Tuesday’s Democratic rout marks a turning point. President Donald Trump isn’t going anywhere, but his spell is broken. This is an accountability moment, and it’s one he can’t gaslight his way out of.

“Midterms are a verdict on the president’s performance, and Trump created the conditions for this one himself. His tariffs and his attack on Iran pushed up living costs in the third straight national election dominated by inflation. His handpicked candidates, from Ken Paxton in Texas to Vivek Ramaswamy in Ohio, set Republicans up for a fall. Even his mid-decade gerrymanders posed no barrier to the blue wave. Many of his own 2024 voters, especially Hispanic and young voters, turned against him.

“But Democrats shouldn’t mistake a thermostatic reaction against Trump for a mandate for the left. Left-wing radicalism isn’t the antidote to right-wing nationalism. A broad coalition that can win and sustain majorities is. Democrats should take their cue from the candidates who just won on the toughest terrain in American politics, and make extending these gains deep into the red zone their mission for 2028.”

Founded in 1989, PPI is a catalyst for policy innovation and political reform based in Washington, D.C. Its mission is to create radically pragmatic ideas for moving America beyond ideological and partisan deadlock. Find an expert and learn more about PPI by visiting progressivepolicy.org. Follow us at @ppi.

###

Media Contact: Ian O’Keefe – iokeefe@ppionline.org

Ainsley in The Guardian: ‘The World Is Out of Control’: How Political Strategist Claire Ainsley Is Challenging the Left to Take It Back

Do you ever feel as if life is spiralling out of control? As if the world’s problems are too big, or politicians too small, to get a grip on everything from rising prices to emergent threats such as AI?

If so, says the political strategist Claire Ainsley, you’re neither alone nor irrational. “It’s probably because you’ve got a lot to do, and the world is out of control,” she says cheerfully from her home in York, where she lives with her husband, an artist, and their two teenage children. But it is the politicians’ job to master fast-moving and complex events, she adds, and if conventional parties seem increasingly powerless to do anything about them, then populist alternatives will be only too ready with dangerously easy-sounding answers.

Her new book Control: How We Lost It and How to Take It Back argues that the centre-left can tackle that fatally undermining sense of impotence by rewiring government and putting people back in charge of their own lives. “We know the rightwing populists have an agenda that is dangerous and divisive. The question is what is being done to stop it,” says Ainsley, who served as Keir Starmer’s director of policy in opposition and is now a consultant for the Washington-based thinktank Progressive Policy Institute. “It’s that lack of leadership from centre-left politicians that people are crying out for.”

Continue reading in The Guardian.

Marshall for The Hill: Can New Leaders Stop Israel’s Slide Into Isolation?

Israeli voters thronged to the polls in record numbers this week, only to produce a frustratingly murky verdict. It may take weeks of haggling among the country’s fragmented political parties to form a new governing coalition — or to decide the country needs a new election.

Although Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu lost his parliamentary majority, the variable geometry of Israeli politics means he could retain his post, possibly in a new unity government between opposed parties.

Americans may not much care who holds power in Jerusalem, but they should. After all, it was Netanyahu who persuaded President Trump to join Israel’s war to topple Iran’s Islamist regime. The regime remains, but Americans are paying dearly for weapons, gas and diesel as the war drags on.

Keep reading in The Hill.

Marshall for The Hill: Trump Wins Elections But Fails at Governing

Nobody plays the victim like President Trump. His self-portrayal is that of a comic book superhero waging a lonely battle against sinister forces bent on eliminating him so they can get on with destroying America.

Biased political reporters, deep state globalists, judges and Supreme Court justices who keep striking down his illegal power grabs, Republican turncoats, commie Democrats, freeloading U.S. allies, a Nobel Prize committee that stubbornly refuses to recognize his superlative contributions to world peace. Trump’s foes are legion.

From Pope Leo on down, anyone who dares oppose or simply disagree with our thin-skinned whiner-in-chief invites a fusillade of Trumpian invective. The trick here — what makes his big con work — is his ability to convince the MAGA faithful that his critics are all effete elitists who hate America and look down on ordinary working folks like them.

But it turns out that objective reality gets a vote too. No amount of presidential gaslighting can overcome the felt experience of U.S. voters. Too many working Americans don’t like what they’re experiencing today, and most blame Trump. Once again, he’s proving to be his own worst enemy.

Keep reading in The Hill.

Marshall for The Hill: On Immigration, Democrats Should Look to the Nordic Model

As Democrats and other center-left parties struggle to understand why working-class voters have turned against them, they reach readily for economic explanations. Yet most flinch from confronting another potent driver of blue-collar anger — uncontrolled immigration.

Of course, that’s partly an economic issue too. But it also illuminates the deep rift between elite and popular opinion on emotive questions of national sovereignty, cultural identity and democratic agency in deciding who can enter one’s country and become a citizen.

Stopping illegal immigration has been President Trump’s most reliable rallying cry. His call to wall America off from a flood of “criminal aliens” in 2016 helped him forge a strong bond with non-college voters. He went back to the immigration well in his 2024 comeback, when those voters again ranked the issue as a top concern, second only to high living costs.

Hostility to mass migration also is the rocket fuel propelling neo-nationalist populists in Europe. These include the far-right Alternative for Germany party, which recently made startling gains in state elections; France’s National Rally, now leading polls ahead of next year’s presidential election, and the United Kingdom’s fast-rising Reform Party.

Read more in The Hill.

Ainsley on The Spectator Podcast Coffee House Shots: Can Andy Keep Up With His Promises?

Andy Burnham delivered his first conference speech as Prime Minister in Liverpool yesterday, promising a sweeping expansion of public services and a fresh look at Brexit, to warm reviews from the hall. Patrick Gibbons is joined by Isabel Hardman and Claire Ainsley, Sir Keir Starmer’s former director of policy, to weigh up what was promised and how the party is taking it.

Kahlenberg for The Atlantic: How the Culture War Put Public Schools at Risk

For more than half a century after Milton Friedman proposed using taxpayer money to support students in private schools, the libertarian economist’s idea went almost nowhere. Republican presidents, including Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush, pushed vouchers—which help parents enroll their children in schools of their choice, including private and religious schools, at taxpayer expense—as a way to liberate poor children from failing big-city school districts. Those efforts led to voucher initiatives in a smattering of districts, such as Cleveland, Milwaukee, and Washington, D.C. But in state after state, support for public schools—which take all comers and have historically played a crucial role in cultivating students’ common identity as Americans—was just too broad-based and too strong to get voucher-like programs approved on a larger scale.

In the past several years, though, voucher advocates have switched strategies to take advantage of the country’s ever-deepening political polarization. In 2022, the Heritage Foundation urged the voucher movement “to embrace the culture war” as a way of promoting school choice. As evidence of progressive overreach, the conservative think tank has pointed to “racial essentialism for third graders” and decried the presence in some school libraries of Gender Queer, a graphic novel that “features a picture of oral sex being performed on a sex toy.”

Conservative leaders in many state capitals have emulated Heritage’s tactics, and the tactical shift has helped persuade lawmakers to expand the supply of school vouchers. Amy Sinclair, the president of the Iowa state Senate, told an interviewer in 2023 that during the coronavirus pandemic, “many parents became aware of anti-American and explicit materials in their child’s classrooms and began to demand choice.” “There’s no reason why any students should have a woke agenda pushed on them,” Texas Governor Greg Abbott declared a month later at a rally for private-school-choice legislation. The following year, his Arkansas counterpart, Sarah Huckabee Sanders, promoted her school-choice efforts by declaring on X, “We need kids learning math, reading, and science—not woke nonsense.” Since the pandemic, voucher-like programs have proliferated, and they are now open to even the richest students. In 2021, no states had universal programs supporting private education with public dollars; by 2025, 18 did. The number of students using publicly funded private-school-choice programs has tripled since the 2018–19 school year.

Read more in The Atlantic.

Marshall in Mainichi: Democratic Party’s Left-Wing Candidates May Struggle to Expand Support in Battleground States Ahead of Midterm Elections

As momentum grows for the left wing of the Democratic Party ahead of the U.S. midterm elections, Will Marshall, president of the Progressive Policy Institute, a think tank associated with moderate Democrats, discussed the party’s prospects in an interview with The Mainichi.

Given the current political environment, Democrats have a good chance of winning back the House of Representatives in this year’s midterm elections. However, I do not expect a landslide victory like the one seen in 2018 during President Trump’s first term.

Democratic and Republican voters have become increasingly entrenched, and there are fewer seats that can realistically change hands.

The biggest reason for the growth of left-wing groups such as the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) is frustration within the Democratic Party itself.

The party’s defeat in the 2024 presidential election was a profound shock. Faced with President Trump pushing laws and democratic norms to their limits, Democrats have felt powerless to stop him. As a result, left-wing populism has gained strength, and demands for maximum resistance and confrontation have grown louder.

Read the Mainichi interview here.

Read the English translation here. 

Steitz for MS Now: Trump’s New Defense for His Arch Is Absurd – And Dangerous

Let’s be clear: No matter what President Donald Trump may say, the national security of the United States does not require the construction of a massive arch in the middle of a traffic circle.

In a saner world, this would not need to be said. But on Friday, the president announced a new purpose for the 250-foot-tall tourist attraction he is seeking to build in the roundabout at the end of Washington’s Memorial Bridge. The arch will double as a “military complex,” Trump said, housing drones and ammo while providing a platform for snipers.

What possible threat aimed at Arlington National Cemetery — of all places — requires the construction of a marble-and-gold arch?

Throughout his second term, Trump has repeatedly invoked flimsy national security excuses to justify policy priorities both big and small. The arch might be the most ludicrous example yet: By claiming that this obvious vanity project is in fact a top Pentagon priority, the administration is clearly hoping it can convince U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan to reconsider her injunction pausing its construction.

My guess is that the argument will get laughed out of court. But that leaves a bigger issue: Judges have long given presidents vast leeway when it comes to national security decisions. Trump’s obvious abuse of that privilege has started forcing them to rethink that stance, which could make it harder to deal with a real emergency in the future.

Read more in MS Now.

Marshall for The Hill: The Center-Left Needs to Step Up and Show America What It Stands For

These are tough times for center-left parties, which increasingly find themselves squeezed into a shrinking middle ground by populist insurgents on the right and left. Few are rising to the challenge of offering restive voters an inspiring alternative to populist prescriptions for sweeping economic and political change.

That leaves most of the political passion and energy churning on the political extremes. MAGA and the Democratic Socialists of America certainly don’t lack bold ideas for change. Even if they do more harm than good, like President Trump’s inflationary tariffs, or unravel under scrutiny, like progressive proposals to abolish private health insurance and pay for a wide array of so-called free public goods by taxing wealth.

But even if they’re peddling snake oil, right- and left-wing populists have sharply defined beliefs and earn points for strong convictions. The center-left, in contrast, suffers from an identity crisis: Voters have only a fuzzy idea of what it stands for. Worse, working-class voters here and across Europe tend to lump center-left and center-right parties into an out-of-touch political establishment that ignores their struggles and governs on behalf of affluent elites and entrenched interests.

What should center-left parties like the Democrats offer voters? Moderation? Compromise and bipartisanship? Political civility? There’s something to be said for each of these, but they don’t add up to a compelling governing philosophy.

Nor is this a time for policy incrementalism. Working Americans are fed up with economic arrangements they see as deeply unfair, the fracturing of our national identity and civic unity and a sclerotic federal government’s inability to get big things done. They’re looking for structural remedies for structural problems.

Democrats aren’t condemned to vapid centrism. They only need to dust off their own rich legacy of bold and modernizing reform rooted in America’s liberal tradition.

Read more in The Hill