Trump-Xi-Putin Summit Reactions

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

Trump-Xi-Putin Summit Reactions

By Danielle Steitz

President Donald Trump met Thursday with his Chinese and Russian counterparts, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, in a trilateral summit in Shenzhen, China. The summit, billed as the first of its kind between the leaders of the three nations, resulted in a joint statement from the three heads of state that the White House called a “declaration towards peace.” The statement included calls for UN reform and increased petroleum production, as well as the conduct of a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and a warning to the International Criminal Court not to abuse its jurisdiction. The leaders also reportedly discussed the war in Ukraine, a topic President Trump has prioritized in efforts to reach a negotiated settlement, but Russian President Putin told reporters after the trilateral discussion that Ukraine and Europe were “not yet ready” to compromise and that Russia would not negotiate after Ukraine’s strike on the Kerch Bridge earlier this week.  

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: This trilateral summit between American, Chinese, and Russian leaders appears to have resulted in little movement on President Trump’s stated pre-summit priorities of ending the wars in Ukraine and Iran and finding a new agreement on nuclear weapons. What it has undoubtedly done, however, is legitimize Vladimir Putin’s Russia as a co-equal on the level of the United States and China, giving Putin long-sought validation that the world shares his view of Russia as a global superpower. It is surreal to see Putin, whose war of aggression against Ukraine is poised to enter its fifth year, sit at the same table as the American president and claim “we hold joint responsibility for maintaining international peace and security.” The inclusion of language recognizing that “the principle of state consent and respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance” in the castigation of the ICC is also a major win for Putin, who has not only managed to convince the American president that they are friends, but that the ICC warrant against him for war crimes in Ukraine should hold no meaning. The actions and rhetoric of the Trump administration against the ICC and the very concept of international law continue to erode the foundations of international order in favor of Trump’s “strongman” theory of the world — a theory Americans of all political stripes should recognize as dangerous and ought to disavow. 

Marco Rubio’s “Men With Swords” Take on International Law 

By Danielle Steitz

President Trump’s dual-hatted Secretary of State and National Security Advisor Marco Rubio delivered the keynote address at last week’s Federalist Society national convention, where he argued against the ability of international institutions and international law to serve as a check on American actions. Rubio took particular aim at the International Criminal Court, touting the Trump administration’s sanctions on the “fake court,” which he referred to as an “unelected world tribunal” that has joined with “its allies in the global bureaucracy” to appoint themselves “judge, jury, and executioner of the international order.” In a soundbite that was later amplified by Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth on social media, Rubio responded to hypothetical ICC enforcement attempts by quoting Roman general Pompey Magnus, stating, “stop quoting laws to men with swords.”

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: If only Senator Marco Rubio were around to see the way Secretary of State Marco Rubio speaks about international law and global order. The one-time believer in the international community’s ability to police its members, who spoke of crimes against humanity and fundamental rights and the “internationally-recognized right to freedom of expression,” and pushed for the “global bureaucracy” to advance human rights in nations like North Korea and Nicaragua, has become unrecognizable in his attempt to amass power and influence in the “might makes right” world of Trumpian foreign policy. The Rubio of today speaks of international law and the “quote-unquote ‘rules-based order’” as “alien to who we are,” an ahistorical understanding that omits a fundamental truth: that America is the nation that created the rules-based order in the first place. As stated above, Americans of all stripes should move beyond this short-sighted “strongman” view that is inconsistent with America’s national character and instead recommit to the fundamental American values of liberty, freedom, and justice across the world. 

Nationwide Systems Outages Put Cyber Infrastructure in the Spotlight

By Danielle Steitz

The month of November has seen several major system outages that have impacted air travel, online banking, digital services from Microsoft and Apple, and even the classified internal network of the National Security Agency. The cluster of high-profile and disruptive outages has drawn questions from politicians and the American public as to whether these incidents are the result of cyberattacks by malicious actors. On Wednesday, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton, and FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia testified before Congress that based on available information, these incidents are not the result of malicious cyber attacks, but rather are the result of separate outages associated with “maintenance and technical changes” across these networks and systems.  

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: While the timing of so many major incidents within such a short timespan is bound to raise some eyebrows, it does (somewhat ironically) appear that these outages are occurring as a result of companies and agencies doing much-needed system upgrades or network vulnerability patching. For instance, DNI Clayton has pointed to patching of the PHP2Shell vulnerabilities discovered last month as the culprit for NSA’s system outage, citing system infrastructure that reacted to patching in unexpected ways. The nationwide FAA ground stop that threw air travel into chaos also appears to be related to a hardware update that resulted in older router hardware being overwhelmed and creating a cascading disruption. Much of the nation’s cyber infrastructure systems were designed and created for a very different era of the internet than the one we live in now, and the pace of modern technology is illuminating the stress fractures and weak points in that existing infrastructure in real time. As companies and government agencies seek to accelerate the pace with which they patch vulnerabilities in response to the AI-fueled “vulnopocalypse,” it is likely that we continue to see systems respond in unexpected ways to those patches, causing further disruptions during this time of rapid transition in our cyber architecture. 

The Lame-Duck Session and Pentagon Priorities 

By Danielle Steitz

The Senate Appropriations Committee this week unveiled its $1.1 trillion defense spending bill for fiscal year 2027, a number that falls slightly below House and Senate authorizers’ $1.14 trillion topline and substantially below the $1.5 trillion request from the Trump administration. The administration’s budget request was structured as $1.15 trillion in the base budget and another $350 billion in a party-line reconciliation bill; however, despite lobbying this week from Deputy Secretary of Defense Steve Feinberg for a defense reconciliation bill, House Armed Services Committee Chairman Mike Rogers has stated that $350 billion “is not going to happen.” Rogers left the door open for a reconciliation bill in the $100 billion range to deal with “the hole in the defense budget that Venezuela and Iran have created,” seemingly shifting the purpose of the bill from longer-term program investment into a supplemental to pay for increased operations costs. 

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: Between the NDAA, the base appropriations bills, and any potential reconciliation or supplemental funding, the lame-duck Congress has a lot of defense-related items on its to-do list and not much time to do them. The odds of a party-line reconciliation bill or supplemental look incredibly long at this point, but SAC-D’s inclusion of nearly $69 billion of funding initially rolled into the reconciliation request in the base bill instead helps to keep funding alive for administration priorities like Golden Dome and rebuilding munitions stockpiles. On the authorization side of the house, both Rogers and HASC Ranking Member Adam Smith have been optimistic about their ability to get the NDAA through in the lame-duck session, and defense policy watchers in D.C. have learned never to bet against the defense policy bill. 

What We’re Reading:

Senators Bennet and Schmitt-led Letter on U.S.-New Zealand Space Cooperation 

Senators Michael Bennet (D-Colo.) and Eric Schmitt (R-Mo.), along with a bipartisan group of seven of their colleagues in the U.S. Senate, recently wrote to Secretary of the Air Force Troy Meink calling for additional steps to strengthen space cooperation with New Zealand. The senators argue that such steps could enhance innovation while also advancing cooperative regional deterrence measures in the Indo-Pacific region. Space capabilities provide the backbone for modern Joint Force operations, and it is certainly in America’s national interest to have capable allies and partners in strategic geographic locations that can interoperate with U.S. forces in the space domain. 

Trump: “We Don’t Need” an Iran Deal

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

Trump: “We Don’t Need” an Iran Deal

By Danielle Steitz

In a Truth Social post on Thursday afternoon, President Donald Trump announced that he was redirecting Vice President J.D. Vance’s efforts away from negotiations with Iran’s leadership and towards combating “crime and corruption at home.” Trump asserted in his post that “we don’t need a deal with Iran,” alleging that America has gotten “hundreds of billions” of dollars from Iran and that “we’ve got their Strait!” Vance had reportedly reached out to Iran’s leaders in the past several days with the hopes of negotiating a settlement to the Iran War, whose unpopularity Vance had identified as the “real reason” for Republicans being routed in the 2026 midterm elections.

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: Trump’s statements about not needing a deal with Iran are in direct contrast to his assertions that a deal with Iran could be reached in the near future, further illustrating the lack of a clear strategy from the Trump administration on how to end the war. At this point, there are few good options on how to bring the war to an end. The status quo is not sustainable; the sizable U.S. military force presence in the region continues to draw assets away from other regions of interest, and every U.S. Navy ship deployed to support commercial traffic through the Strait of Hormuz incurs a maintenance debt that will impact its future availability. Nor is there sufficient political will or public backing to support the kind of military escalation that defeating Iran on the battlefield would likely require. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent appears confident that the economic warfare of his Operation Economic Outcast will “economically asphyxiate” the Iranian regime and force the conclusion of the war on America’s terms; however, what was promised to be an “economic D-Day” in August of 2026 so far appears not to have changed the strategic calculus of Iranian leaders. While the Trump administration has undermined Iran’s faith in American diplomacy several times over — striking Iran while negotiators were at the table in February 2026 and walking away from a signed Memorandum of Understanding this summer — a diplomatic resolution likely remains the only course out of this strategic quagmire.

Hegseth Impeachment Vote Fails

By Danielle Steitz

On Tuesday, the House of Representatives voted to refer Rep. Thomas Massie’s articles of impeachment against Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth to committee, effectively tabling any consideration of the measure on the House floor for the rest of the current Congress. Massie, who lost his primary and will not be returning to Congress next year, drafted 8 articles of impeachment and sought to hold Hegseth accountable for violations of the War Powers Act with respect to the Iran War, extrajudicial boat strikes in the Caribbean, the capture of Venezuelan leader Nicolas Maduro, and retaliation against Democratic Senator Mark Kelly. Hegseth has largely been the face of the very unpopular Iran War, and he struck a defiant tone in a rare Pentagon press conference on Tuesday morning, arguing that going after him would be putting a target on the backs of American servicemembers.

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: The Massie articles of impeachment always faced an uphill battle — their passage would have required full Democratic voting support and significant Republican defections, neither of which occurred – but it seems very unlikely that this means the end of Hegseth’s battles with Congress. Democratic leader and presumed future Speaker Hakeem Jeffries deferred to incoming HASC chairman Adam Smith on any future impeachment efforts, with Smith striking a measured tone but leaving the door open to possible removal in the 120th Congress. With the return of HASC’s Oversight and Investigations subcommittee in the next Congress, I anticipate a number of investigations aimed at substantiating potentially impeachable actions, such as: the short-circuiting of officer promotion processes for his own preferred criteria; his sharing of classified military operational information via a Signal group chat; and the activities of the Office of Strategic Capital, whose direct equity stake-taking and involvement in the transfer of Venezuelan oil to U.S. control appear legally dubious.

The NDAA Clock Is Ticking 

By Danielle Steitz

With the 119th Congress firmly entering the “lame-duck” part of its tenure, one must-pass piece of legislation remains at the top of the House and Senate Armed Services Committees’ to-do list: the annual National Defense Authorization Act, or NDAA. The NDAA has passed for 65 consecutive years and is considered a “must-pass” bill in every Congress; its reputation and the shared House and Senate goal of passing it each year often make it a very popular vehicle for a host of Republican and Democratic legislative priorities. The “big 4” committee leaders from both HASC and SASC reportedly plan to meet multiple times next week to find a path forward on major sticking points in the defense authorization bill, to include the topline appropriations for the Department of Defense and funding for the Iran War.

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: The to-do list for the “big 4” appears to only be growing as Congress looks to the NDAA to advance key legislative priorities. In addition to hammering out a compromise topline below the DoD’s $1.5 trillion total ask and the future of Iran War funding, negotiators must also sort out what to do with language governing the DoD Office of Strategic Capital’s ability to take direct equity stakes, so-called “right to repair” provisions that industry argues could improperly siphon up their intellectual property, and a provision that aims to deepen U.S.-Israeli cooperation on defense innovation. On top of all of that, both Democratic and Republican House leaders have seized on the revelation of Nvidia CEO Jenson Huang’s inappropriate relationship with a suspected Chinese intelligence operative to call for the incorporation of several chip and semiconductor export-control measures into the NDAA. With such a long list of priorities, HASC and SASC leadership and their staff won’t have much opportunity to relax during the lame-duck session.

What We’re Reading

How the World Ran Out of Everything: Inside the Global Supply Chain by Peter S. Goodman

Goodman’s 2024 work, written in the shadow of the COVID-19 pandemic’s very tangible supply chain breakdowns, provides an excellent entry point into understanding the current state of play of global supply chains for readers without an economics or business background. In How the World Ran Out of Everything, Goodman illustrates the vast and fragile networks that underpin contemporary manufacturing, long optimized for “just in time” delivery and minimal manufacturing overhead. The lessons of COVID-19, of disrupted delivery and supply chain chokepoints, are just as likely to apply to any potential conflict with China — we should heed their lessons now and reconsider optimizing for resilience and durability in our supply chains instead.

Was This a Foreign Policy Election?

Welcome to a special post-midterms edition of Domain Awareness! Tuesday night’s Democratic victories are poised to usher in an entirely blue Congress come January 2027, with major implications for defense and national security policy. Below, find PPI’s analysis on some of the major storylines to watch in the lame-duck session and beyond.

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

Was This a Foreign Policy Election?

By Danielle Steitz

As Republican politicians and party officials grapple with how to move forward after devastating electoral results, party leaders from Vice President JD Vance to Texas Senator Ted Cruz and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis have all pointed fingers at the same leading cause of voters’ nationwide rejection of Republican candidates: the deeply unpopular war with Iran. As the war initially pitched as a three-week operation drags into its ninth month with approval ratings hovering in the low-to-mid 30s, its financial impacts have hit Americans’ wallets hard. NBC News’s latest data shows a 37.5% increase in national gas prices since the start of the Iran War, while the price of food was 2.5% higher in September 2026 than September 2025 — a major blow to Republicans in an election cycle where 4 in 10 voters cited the economy as the top issue facing the country.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: A number of remarkable things not seen in decades happened on Election Day: Texas candidates won every statewide race, many for the first time since the 1990s; Senator-elect Annie Andrews broke a 28-year Republican hold on the Senate in South Carolina; Congressman-elect Sam Forstag is the first Democrat elected to Congress in Montana in three decades. For many online policy commentators and talking heads, it seemed as though the 2026 midterm elections, full of surprising events, had turned into that rarest of things — a foreign policy election. These commentators were not alone in their belief that the deeply unpopular Iran War had turned the electoral tides against Republican majorities (see the list of Republicans above who stated the same). It is undeniable that the conflict represents two major broken promises by President Donald Trump from his 2024 campaign, lower costs for Americans and no new wars, and that voters expressed their disapproval and anger at the ballot box. However, can this result be seen as a repudiation of Trump’s foreign policy writ large?

The short answer is that while foreign policy experts and political junkies across America and the rest of the Western world might hope that this result means a return to normalcy in American foreign relations, this election simply was not a referendum on foreign policy. It was a cost-of-living election where the two clearest causes of increased prices just so happen to be foreign policy choices in the form of the Iran War and tariffs. Those who assert the election results to be a clear sign that their preferred course for Democratic or American foreign policy is the only path forward — that it means Democrats should “truly become the antiwar party” or that the alienation of allies and “how we show up in the world” were motivating factors for voters — should be paid no heed. When fewer than 1 in 10 voters say that foreign policy is their top issue, it’s best to take them at their word and to recognize, in the words of James Carville, that “it’s the economy, stupid.”

Knives Out for Pete Hegseth? 

By Danielle Steitz

Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth has never boasted strong support from congressional Republicans — his 51-50 confirmation vote required Vice President JD Vance’s tie-breaking support — but with the economic implications of America’s war with Iran front and center in voters’ ballot-box calculus, the party’s desire to pin the blame on Hegseth seems to have hit a new high. NBC News reports that President Trump has told allies he’s considering replacing Hegseth, who has drawn the ire of Democrats and Republicans alike over the past two years and who could face a vote on his impeachment as soon as the House returns to town thanks to articles introduced by Republican congressman Thomas Massie.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: Pete Hegseth has won himself very few friends on Capitol Hill during his tenure at the Pentagon. He has exhibited a defiant and dismissive attitude towards congressional oversight that has frustrated both Democrats and Republicans, failing to communicate about major personnel decisions and the administration’s Iran strategy and leaving Congress in the dark. Hegseth’s partisan push for a $350 billion party-line reconciliation bill and a $60 billion Iran War supplemental further irritated both parties, particularly as Democrats were excluded from classified budget briefings in a break with decades of bipartisan precedent. While Massie’s vote in a lame-duck Republican House is unlikely to succeed, Hegseth is already in the crosshairs of Democrats like Congressmen Jason Crow and Pat Ryan, who are eager for his impeachment. Although Trump has so far publicly stood by his Defense Secretary, he has also stated that Hegseth would be “very popular” if selected to fill Tennessee Senator Marsha Blackburn’s seat. Trump has also acknowledged that it would be much easier to confirm a replacement in the lame-duck session while the Senate is still under Republican control, providing a smoother path to confirmation for someone like rumored contender Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida.

Changes Coming to Defense Committees

By Danielle Steitz

The membership and composition of the congressional defense committees will look drastically different come January 2027. In the Senate, the retirements of Gary Peters, Jeanne Shaheen, and Joni Ernst, as well as a still-uncalled race for Dan Sullivan, leave several vacancies on the Senate Armed Services Committee for incoming chairman Jack Reed to fill. The Senate Appropriations Committee will need a new lead Republican after Susan Collins lost her bid for reelection, and the Defense subcommittee is losing Mitch McConnell, Richard Durbin, and Shaheen to retirement, with another vacancy potentially arising if Cindy Hyde-Smith loses a close race in Mississippi.

Turning to the House, several HASC Republicans were on the losing end of some of the most surprising races of the midterms. Some races are still uncalled, but if current vote margins hold, HASC is poised to see the departure of 14 Republican members to retirement or losses, with longtime members Rob Wittman, Mike Turner, and Scott DesJarlais as some of the biggest names not to win reelection. While less turnover is expected on HAC-D, with only David Valadao’s loss called so far and Mario Diaz-Balart still narrowly leading, the House Intelligence Committee is also poised for a big shakeup on the Republican side, with 5 current members either retiring or having lost their reelection campaigns. Meanwhile, the incoming Democratic class boasts a new crop of military veterans, increasing the number of Democrats with military backgrounds to at least 33 and serving as the foundation for a new group of national security leaders in Congress.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: Not only will the chairmanship transition from Republicans to Democrats on these committees, but given the projected margins in both the House and the Senate, the ratio of party representation looks poised to shift heavily towards Democrats as well. No surprises are anticipated in chairman selection; Sen. Jack Reed and Rep. Adam Smith, the current ranking members on SASC and HASC, appear unlikely to face any competition for their gavels. While negotiations between party leaders to set the actual ratios will take place over the next month and a half, expect to see some heavy weighting in Democrats’ favor on House committees like Appropriations and Armed Services, and increased Dem representation on their counterpart committees in the Senate.

What We’re Reading

Statement on HASC Democrats’ Priorities for the 120th Congress from Congressman Adam Smith (D-WA)

Rep. Adam Smith, current ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee, is set to take the gavel in January for a committee rich with bipartisan tradition, but which faces the Herculean task of balancing oversight of a less-than-transparent Pentagon with advancing good and thoughtful defense policy. Smith outlines oversight as the top priority, with HASC bringing back its Oversight & Investigations subcommittee to scrutinize illegal and unauthorized military activity in Iran and the Caribbean as well as potential conflicts of interest in the award of Pentagon contracts. He also points to the need to set a “realistic and sustainable approach” to national security and defense budgets, continuity of acquisition reform efforts, and a focus on undoing the culture of politicization around military and civilian personnel management.

Marshall for The Hill: Can New Leaders Stop Israel’s Slide Into Isolation?

Israeli voters thronged to the polls in record numbers this week, only to produce a frustratingly murky verdict. It may take weeks of haggling among the country’s fragmented political parties to form a new governing coalition — or to decide the country needs a new election.

Although Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu lost his parliamentary majority, the variable geometry of Israeli politics means he could retain his post, possibly in a new unity government between opposed parties.

Americans may not much care who holds power in Jerusalem, but they should. After all, it was Netanyahu who persuaded President Trump to join Israel’s war to topple Iran’s Islamist regime. The regime remains, but Americans are paying dearly for weapons, gas and diesel as the war drags on.

Keep reading in The Hill.

Cybersecurity’s “Black October”

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

Cybersecurity’s “Black October”

By Danielle Steitz

The warnings of experts alarmed by the proliferation of AI-enabled cyber threats reached a new pitch this month, already coined “Black October” by cybersecurity professionals and drawing parallels to March of 2020. The discovery of critical vulnerabilities in the programming language PHP, which underpins more than 70% of the Internet’s webpages, was the banner event that drew attention to the slew of vulnerabilities and exploits that have recently been exposed by AI tools. Earlier in the month, the Japanese government declared a “state of emergency in cyberspace” after a surge of cyberattacks targeted government websites, banks, and transit organizations, while South Korea experienced a series of cyberattacks against financial institutions that CrowdStrike assessed were launched by a single individual utilizing agentic AI tools. As 404Media’s Jason Koebler puts it, “AI is proving something that we have always known: much of the software that runs the internet, our devices, our accounts, and our lives is vulnerable,” and the availability of AI models has “made it extremely easy to essentially brute force the internet.”

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: In the past, the biggest barriers to a “brute force” or “try every doorknob” approach to hacking have been technical prowess (knowing enough to understand what you’re looking at and where the doorknob even is) and time (you can only try one or a few doorknobs at a time). AI models — both top-of-the-line frontier models as well as open-source models available online — have drastically reduced the technical know-how needed to find exploits and hack systems, while also eliminating time-based limits by operating 24/7 without needing to pause for sleep or other tasks. This means that some targets that might have been previously passed over by hackers — small hospitals, local electric utilities, and other key service providers who might have once been judged to not be worth the time and effort to hack – must now accept that there is no hiding, and invest and prepare accordingly. While nobody knows the full extent to which AI might reshape cybersecurity — some experts still remain hopeful that AI’s utility in patching vulnerabilities will ultimately result in a more secure cyber architecture — one thing appears clear: building resilient systems is paramount. Individuals and organizations should assume it’s a matter of when, not if, they will be hacked, and invest in developing their ability to identify intrusions, repel the attack, mitigate damage, and resume normal operations.

Bolsonaro’s Election Denial

By Danielle Steitz

A hotly contested election this week in Brazil has been marred by accusations of fraud and illegitimacy. Flávio Bolsonaro, the right-wing opponent to incumbent Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, has fled to Florida after the Brazilian public voted to reelect Lula by a margin of roughly 5 million votes. Flávio appears to be following in the footsteps of his father, disgraced former president Jair Bolsonaro, who fled to Florida after losing to and attempting a coup against Lula in 2022,  and who is currently serving a 27-year sentence under house arrest in Brazil for his crimes. Flávio and his family arrived in Miami on Wednesday despite Flávio’s passport having been confiscated by Brazilian authorities as part of a Supreme Court investigation into charges of corruption, tax evasion and money laundering. Despite this cloud of suspicion, Bolsonaro apparently entered the U.S. with President Trump’s approval, as the American president has publicly called the election “really strange” and “rigged.” Trump declined, however, to comment on Flávio’s statement, in which he declared himself the rightful leader of Brazil and called for the election results to be annulled.

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: Trump’s domestic election denialism and degradation of faith in electoral results have gone global, with Bolsonaro as his latest right-wing ally to copy his playbook. Bolsonaro’s insistence that he is the true winner of the election flies in the face of his own party’s acceptance of the results as well as the recognition by international governments of Lula’s victory, but looks very similar to Trump’s 2020 election denials. Trump’s decision to offer refuge to a man fleeing investigation in his own country after his focus on deporting “criminal immigrants” comes across as hypocritical, but it’s not surprising in light of his administration’s reported support for the Bolsonaro family. As my colleague Ed Gresser noted this week, all of this takes place against the backdrop of a pessimistic global environment for electoral democracies.

Hegseth’s Latest Fired General

By Danielle Steitz

Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth has relieved yet another distinguished general officer from a leadership post, this time removing LTG Brett Sylvia, a 32-year Army veteran, from his position as director of the Joint Staff’s Directorate for Strategy, Plans, and Policy (J5). An unnamed senior Pentagon official provided a statement to a select group of news outlets alleging that LTG Sylvia had been fired for leaking classified information to reporters concerning the war with Iran, Ukraine, and other matters, and that an investigation had been referred to the Justice Department. The Joint Staff initially put out a statement wishing LTG Sylvia and his family well as they transitioned into their next chapter, only to later retract it, claiming that “the statement did not appropriately reflect the full circumstances” and declining to comment further “out of respect for the servicemember and the ongoing personnel process.”

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: First and foremost, leaking classified information is a criminal activity, and as a former Joint Staff officer, I do not take the obligation to safeguard classified information lightly in the slightest. With that said, it is impossible to assess this latest firing without acknowledging a clear pattern of behavior from Pete Hegseth whereby allegations of leaking have been made against multiple officials with no substantiating evidence ever presented. In fact, Hegseth’s former special advisor Dan Caldwell, who was fired last year for allegedly leaking information, has since been rehired into the administration as a senior advisor to the Director of National Intelligence — certainly not a position given to an adjudicated leaker. It is also critical to note that, given LTG JP McGee’s accelerated retirement last fall, this is the second J5 that has been pushed out in the past year. Given that the position of the J5 is essentially the Joint Staff counterpart to Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby, as well as Hegseth’s clear preference for surrounding himself with “yes men”, it seems possible that personality clashes or diverging perspectives between Sylvia and Hegseth or Colby are now being twisted into more severe allegations to justify Sylvia’s removal. I anticipate the congressional oversight committees’ continued focus on the personnel moves and rationales offered by the Hegseth Pentagon, with particular scrutiny on what evidence substantiates these allegations of criminal behavior by a decorated senior officer.

What We’re Reading

“Zelensky Stood Up to Trump and Came Out Ahead—For Now” by Tamar Jacoby in Washington Monthly

Tamar Jacoby, director of PPI’s New Ukraine project, has just published her analysis on who won the latest round of escalating tensions between Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and the Donald Trump-led United States. Her verdict? Zelensky has more shrewdly judged both the political moment and weathered drastic U.S. restrictions on Starshield, U.S. intelligence sharing, and Patriot interceptors to emerge with world opinion firmly on his side.

Ukraine Blindsided by Starlink Satellite Restrictions

Explosive reporting by The Wall Street Journal this week asserts that SpaceX CEO Elon Musk is responsible for ordering speed restrictions on Ukrainian drones connecting to Starshield, the military application of SpaceX’s Starlink satellite network. The speed restrictions impacted both offensive and interceptor drones, reducing their effectiveness against Russian missiles and making them easier targets for Russian air defense systems. The Wall Street Journal report comes after days of finger-pointing and blame-shifting between the White House and Musk, and cites several sources who say that Musk had conversations with multiple senior administration officials — to include President Trump — before instituting the restrictions. Meanwhile, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is still pleading for resolution, asking the Trump administration to restore Starshield connectivity and allow Ukraine to defend itself against continued Russian attacks.

PPI Expert Analysis:

Tamar Jacoby, Kyiv-based director of PPI’s New Ukraine project: Nearly five years since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, virtually every frontline unit has adapted to the decentralized, drone-centered way of war that is the hallmark of this conflict. Every unit has its own IT shop to assemble and upgrade unmanned vehicles for its own specific tactical needs. Small, run-of-the-mill units may have just a few men in a backroom or a bunker. Larger, elite units have extensive facilities — dozens of technicians, complicated public and private supply lines, even their own proprietary manufacturing for some essential components. What they all have in common: the platforms they prepare for combat — be they aerial, ground, or maritime unmanned systems — rely on Starlink. You can’t miss the branded boxes stacked in every frontline outpost — in humbler units, just a few cartons shoved under a cot or behind a makeshift stove; at more advanced workshops, often several packed storerooms full of still uncrated late-model terminals.

Without Starlink or its military iteration, Starshield, the Ukrainian military would be virtually blind. Uncrewed strike units rely on it for targeting midrange assaults on enemy supply depots up to 200 kilometers behind the front line. Assault troops count on it to control the short-range drones that police and protect them in the kill zone. Interceptor teams in Kyiv and other cities depend on it to shoot down the incoming enemy drones — Shaheds and their progeny — that have terrorized Ukrainian civilian life since autumn 2022.

Russia’s new reliance on jet-powered drones — which fly more than twice as fast as those with piston engines — has made high-speed Starshield more essential than ever. Without it, Ukrainian air defense units have little chance of protecting civilian life in Kyiv and other cities. Ukraine doesn’t disaggregate civilian casualty figures — how many people were killed and wounded by jet drones as distinct from cruise and ballistic missiles. But there’s no question that the recent slowdown — the software adjustments ordered by Elon Musk last week that limit the speed of Starshield-guided platforms — is costing civilian lives.

Rarely, if ever, before in the history of warfare has one man — one unelected, civilian entrepreneur with no political check or balance — held so much power over the course of a conflict. How can this be right? How have we allowed it to happen? What can be done to limit Musk’s outsized influence on the battlefield? It’s every soldier’s nightmare come true — a magic weapon with a kill switch — and it will haunt the U.S. defense industry for years to come, as governments around the world think twice about purchasing American weapons that rely on software an army in harm’s way cannot control.

Mary Guenther, Head of Space Policy: Europe’s trust in American commercial space capabilities has been severely eroded in light of Ukrainian military access to SpaceX’s connectivity services being cut off or severely degraded not just once, but now twice. This is only egged on by Trump’s statements indicating American military products sold abroad may have a kill switch. While many commercial space services are used for purely civil purposes in Europe, like wildfire detection, most are dual-use, meaning they have civil and defense applications.

In Europe, distrust in American commercial space services has accelerated efforts to develop sovereign capabilities to avoid relying on the United States for their defense. Sovereign European capabilities are not a bad thing — the United States has been pushing for Europe to take greater responsibility for its defenses for some time — but an aversion to American commercial space companies based on the actions of one company and one Administration hurts the domestic space economy writ large, which relies on supply chains and markets on both sides of the Atlantic.

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: The perception that certain Trump administration officials (such as Secretary of State Marco Rubio) have fostered — that this disruption was caused by Elon Musk acting unilaterally to dramatically alter the state of U.S. military assistance to Ukraine — is not only dangerous, it also illustrates the two-faced nature of Trump’s Ukraine policy. This is a president who continues to berate Ukraine’s leaders, demanding new elections and a cessation of strikes on Russian energy infrastructure, and who has directed actions and policy measures designed to force Ukraine to accede to unjust terms. However, once the tragic consequences of degrading Ukraine’s self-defense capabilities have been made clear to the world, Trump reversed course after several days of finger-pointing and reportedly asked Musk to restore Ukraine’s full capability. While the blame games continue to play out in Washington media outlets, those who suffer most from this Jekyll-and-Hyde decision-making are the Ukrainian citizens who now face the onset of another winter under Russian attack.

Commercial Satellite Intentionally Shadowed by Russia

By Mary Guenther and Danielle Steitz

In the first known encounter of its kind, a Russian government satellite recently conducted a nonconsensual, close-proximity rendezvous with a Western commercial satellite, raising eyebrows as to what message Russia is looking to send. Between October 15 and 19, tracking data showed a Russian government satellite known as Kosmos-2612 intentionally synchronizing its orbit to coincide with that of ICEYE X-36, a commercial satellite that provides synthetic aperture radar data to ICEYE customers, including Ukraine. Kosmos-2612 conducted a deliberate set of maneuvers that at times put it a mere 100-500 meters away from ICEYE X-36, sending worrisome signals about Russia’s willingness to challenge the West in space as well as on Earth.

PPI Expert Analysis:

Mary Guenther, Head of Space Policy: It’s no longer groundbreaking to acknowledge that space is a warfighting domain, but it’s safe to say that nobody wants space war anytime soon. Unfortunately, this provocation from Russia gets us one step closer to that undesirable outcome as adversaries are escalating within the space arena. While Russia does not appear to have done anything beyond a close approach that could support their intelligence collection on satellites being used to support operations in Ukraine, this could be practice to build up to any number of harmful actions, from intercepting satellite signals, kinetically destroying the satellite, or using other mechanisms to disable it.

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: To add to Mary’s point, not only is space very clearly a warfighting domain, but it also appears to be the next domain in Russia’s “grey zone” warfare against the West. It is no secret that Russia has escalated its campaign of grey zone or hybrid warfare against Western nations over the last several months: the failed Leipzig Airport attack, expanded drone incursions into NATO nations, and increasing numbers of sabotage attacks all have Vladimir Putin’s fingerprints on them. The deliberate shadowing of ICEYE X-36 by Kosmos-2612 can be seen as the next step in Russia’s campaign, demonstrating Russia’s willingness to extend the grey zone into orbit by signaling its capability to interfere with Western commercial assets.

Politicization of Promotions at the State Department

By Danielle Steitz

The Washington Sun reported this week that the State Department has begun asking foreign service officers who they voted for in the 2016, 2020, and 2024 presidential elections as part of the department’s promotions process. In addition to voting histories, civil service candidates for promotion were also reportedly asked about previous political campaign donations, and were told that any donation to Democratic candidates would be disqualifying for those seeking mid-to-upper-level roles in the Foreign Service. This type of questioning as a promotion consideration appears to be directly in contradiction of federal law, which prohibits personnel decisions for career civil servants from being made on the basis of political affiliation. The State Department has not commented on the voting history questions, but issued a statement emphasizing fidelity to “the president’s vision for foreign policy” and “demonstrated performance on behalf of administration priorities.”

PPI Expert Analysis:

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: The overt politicization of career civil service jobs in the State Department is disheartening, yet unsurprising in the administration of a president who values loyalty to him above all else. Trump’s disregard for career Foreign Service officers has been demonstrated time and again through his preference for sending Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner flying around the world instead of trusting trained and experienced diplomats to handle difficult negotiations, but requiring explicit political support of Trump in order to reach more senior grades is the most blatantly institution-warping act yet. When they join the Foreign Service, these officers swear in their oath of office to support and defend not the policy of a particular president, but the U.S. Constitution. Warping the definition of “fidelity” to mean anything else does a gross disservice to that oath, and to those who take seriously their calling to public service.

Warsaw Security Forum Reflections

** Programming note: Welcome to a special Tuesday edition of Domain Awareness, featuring our recap of the Warsaw Security Forum! We’ll resume our normal format on Thursday this week, but read on for our analysis and takeaways from a very successful and newsy Forum.

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

Warsaw Security Forum Reflections

Congressman Jim Himes in a discussion on “A New European Security Architecture: Is There a Way Back to Strategic Stability?” 

By Danielle Steitz and Tamar Jacoby

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: 

The Warsaw Security Forum took place on October 12th and 13th in Warsaw, Poland, against the backdrop of the war in Ukraine entering its fifth winter and an emboldened Russia conducting hybrid attacks against European nations with increasing frequency. However, the talk of the conference in many ways was President Donald Trump’s announcement just prior to the forum that he had brokered a “diesel deal” with Russian leader Vladimir Putin, which would allow Russia to profit from diesel exports to the United States while allegedly lowering prices at the pump for Americans. Of course, such a deal appeared to European leaders as an absolute betrayal of Ukraine and Europe, who Trump has castigated for years about how slowly Europe’s decoupling from Russian energy has proceeded; speakers at the Forum repeatedly described it as sending all the wrong signals to Europe and to Russia.

In this context, navigating the Forum as an American traveling with two U.S. congressmen — we had the distinct pleasure of having Reps. Jim Himes and Jason Crow join our delegation to Warsaw — was an eye-opening experience. Most Europeans that we engaged with were excited that two American congressmen had taken the time to travel to Europe just before the midterm elections to participate in conversations around the future of the transatlantic relationship. It was evident just how closely European politicians and policymakers are tracking this November’s midterm elections, and how much desire there is for the U.S. Congress to reassert itself as a check on President Trump’s foreign policy.

Time and again, we also heard Europeans reiterate that they are no longer interested in a return to the longtime status quo of Europe as a “junior partner” to the United States. Instead, the new dynamic they foresee for the transatlantic relationship centers around a more “grown-up” or “eye-level” relationship of equal partners, where Europe is increasingly able to hold its own regardless of America’s level of engagement with the continent. It only makes sense — why would these nations go backward when they have made extensive multiyear investments in their own defense over the past several years, and Russia has only gotten bolder in undertaking arson and sabotage activities within Europe’s borders?

As American Democrats await the results of the midterm elections and develop their governance agenda moving forward, they should understand this clearly — there is no “back to normal” that will happen in January 2027 or under a new administration in January 2029. “Superficially, everything is different,” under a Democratic administration, Rep. Himes said, while reiterating that it “is a tectonic fact that there is a consensus in the United States that the cost that was paid in the post-war era… was too high.”

Congressman Himes stated that Europe could expect continued pressure — albeit in a far more diplomatic and less outrageous way than at present—to continue assuming a larger role in European defense. Democratic leaders should be thinking now about a realistic and clear-eyed path vision for the transatlantic relationship, recognizing where it is now and finding practical ways to drive towards where allies and partners agree it ought to be.

Congressman Jason Crow participating in the panel discussion “The West Under Attack: Confronting Malign Powers.” 

Tamar Jacoby, Director of PPI’s New Ukraine Project: 

One takeaway moment stood out among many at last week’s Warsaw Security Forum. The moderator of one panel sought to frame the conversation by turning to the audience — a distinguished group of elected officials, diplomats, defense industry leaders, and military men, most of them from Europe. “How many of you are sure that if Europe is attacked,” she asked, “the U.S. will fulfill its NATO obligation to come to our defense?”

In an audience of perhaps 250, not even 10 hands went up, and most of them were tentative — more half-mast than wholeheartedly sure. Then, over the next two days, countless speakers underlined the point, expressing, often in emotional terms, their feelings of disappointment and betrayal at America’s turn away from the transatlantic alliance.

Nearly two years into Donald Trump’s second term, the American pivot is no longer shocking for Europeans. It’s an established fact, and virtually no one expects it to be reversed, no matter who wins the White House in 2028.

But two existential questions remain, hovering menacingly over the continent. One centers on the future of the alliance: will it survive in any form, and if so, what will it look like? The second question, no less pressing: can Europe reorganize and rearm quickly enough to defend itself with significantly less help from the U.S.?

Conversations that included Americans — both on stage and in the corridors — tended to focus on the first issue. But if anything, most Europeans seemed more concerned about the second.

Panelist after panelist made a version of the same point. Europeans are rearming as fast as they can in the face of what many see as imminent Russian aggression — aiming higher, spending more, manufacturing more, and pushing themselves to what feels like the limit. But it isn’t enough. The continent is far from where it needs to be as the U.S. turns away.

“We spent twice as much on defense in 2026 [as we spent in 2021],” one former defense minister argued heatedly. “We have the money. We have the technology. We have the skilled labor force. We can do it if we want to. The question is, do we want to?” It’s a matter of political will.

In some ways, this was anguishing — hearing from people trying as hard as possible and still coming up short. But it was also encouraging. If the urgency expressed at the Warsaw conference translates into action — national policy, NATO initiatives, EU regulations, defense industry planning and production, civilian awareness campaigns – the continent may rearm fast enough to fill the gaps left by the U.S. pivot.

Speakers largely agreed on the most pressing items on the agenda. Some were technical: strategic enablers, air defense, and military mobility, among others. Also essential: more speed and scale — vastly increased, faster defense production – and incorporating lessons learned from Ukraine.

But by far the most urgent need, most concurred, is cooperation — more continent-wide collective action by countries that have historically seen defense as a national prerogative.

What this would mean in practice: arriving at a shared assessment of the threat, followed by collective planning, pooled procurement, joint defense production, and new mechanisms for faster continent-wide decision-making, including with Ukraine. “We need a new mentality,” one decorated military man argued. “We will not survive without a truly collective defense.”

For an American listener, it made for a bittersweet two days. It was hard not to come away angry at the abrupt way Trump has turned on the alliance that represented and defended American values for three generations. But it was also hard not to feel hopeful about the Europeans pressing their countries to step up and fill the void we’re leaving. “Yes, we are moving too slowly,” one sitting foreign minister conceded. “Yes, we are still too fragmented. But we are finally moving in the right direction.”

Jacoby on Background Briefing: Can the Europeans Defend Ukraine as Trump Tries to Sell Them Out With Bribes From Putin While Blaming Ukraine For the Price of Diesel?

We begin with the European reaction to Trump trying to blame Ukraine for the price of diesel as he again sides with Putin to sell out Ukraine with Putin dangling bribes before our greedy imbecile of a president to line Trump and his family’s pockets. Joining us from the Warsaw Security Forum in Warsaw, Poland is Tamar Jacoby, the Kyiv-based director of the Progressive Policy Institute’s New Ukraine Project. She was a senior writer and justice editor at Newsweek and, before that, the deputy editor of the New York Times op-ed page. She is the author of Displaced: The Ukrainian Refugee Experience and she has an article at The Washington Monthly, “Europeans Look for Options as Costs Mount in Ukraine.”

Listen to the full podcast.

Jacoby for Washington Monthly: Europeans Look for Options as Costs Mount in Ukraine

Ukrainian Finance Minister Serhii Marchenko was in Brussels on September 28, when a Russian drone flew into the National Academy of Sciences, one of the country’s leading research institutes and a symbol of Ukrainian identity. Moscow’s new strategy of round-the-clock bombardment of civilian targets was already more than a month old, but the strike, which killed two academy employees, still came as a shock. The elegant 19th-century building in the center of Kyiv burst into flames, and a huge cloud of black smoke billowed from the open roof as terrified researchers inched out onto window ledges before climbing down ladders to the street.

“War is longer, war is harder,” Marchenko explained soberly to his audience in Belgium. “Russian jet drones are destroying our logistics, our retail storage, our refueling stations, our data centers.” Tax and customs revenues are falling short of expectations, and Kyiv will need more help than anticipated to get through the winter, not to mention the year ahead.

For many in the minister’s audience in Brussels, it isn’t a question of whether to help, but how—where to find the money. Unlike President Donald Trump, who moved last week to lift sanctions on Russian diesel exports, Europe is determined to stand with Ukraine and keep the pressure on Moscow. “There’s no option where we do nothing,” centrist French member of the European Parliament Nathalie Loiseau explained to me a few days after the academy bombing. “We can’t say to Ukraine, ‘Okay, you’re on your own,’” leaving Kyiv to lose a war that many Europeans believe is all that’s stopping Vladimir Putin from turning his guns on NATO.

But after nearly five years of fighting, Europeans are running out of options, which is why the debate is circling back again to an idea proposed and rejected several times in the past—leveraging the Russian Central Bank assets held in European financial institutions.

Gold Star Families and Survivors Speak on Deadly Port Shuaiba Attack

** Programming note: This week, Domain Awareness is rather abridged, but we promise it’s for good reason! PPI’s national security team is on the move this week, with Mary Guenther representing at the International Aeronautical Conference in Turkey, and Danielle Steitz and Tamar Jacoby on their way to Warsaw for this year’s Warsaw Security Forum. We are excited to be working with the Forum as a programming partner, and are delighted to have Rep. Jason Crow and Rep. Jim Himes leading our delegation. If you or a colleague will be in Warsaw and are interested in engaging with some of PPI’s side programming, please feel free to reach out to Danielle Steitz or John Michael Dieng — we’d love to see you there!

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

Gold Star Families and Survivors Speak on Deadly Port Shuaiba Attack

By Danielle Steitz

The Associated Press this week published a moving exclusive report that features firsthand accounts and interviews with survivors and family members of those lost in the Iranian attack on Port Shuaiba, Kuwait. The attack, which took place on March 1, 2026, remains the deadliest known attack on U.S. forces to date, with six soldiers killed and dozens more injured by an Iranian drone strike that targeted the Army’s tactical operations center at Port Shuaiba. New survivor accounts describe Army leaders’ decision-making around force protection at Port Shuaiba despite a shortage of counter-drone defenses and intelligence assessments that identified the port as a likely Iranian target, raising questions as to whether the loss of life could have been avoided.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: One of the most striking aspects of the interviews with soldiers deployed at Port Shuaiba was how clearly unprepared they believed the installation was for the exact kind of Iranian drone attack they experienced. One survivor even commented that the unit’s safety officer, MAJ Cody Khork, had expressed concerns that low-flying drones were not being considered in the issuance of “all-clear” orders — and yet was pushed by higher-ranking officers to clear soldiers to leave the relative safety of concrete bunkers and return to the operations center. MAJ Khork was one of the six soldiers killed when a low-flying drone smashed through the roof of the operations center just minutes after an all-clear had been issued.

Commanders owe a fundamental duty of care to their soldiers when it comes to force protection; while soldiers understand that they may be ordered into harm’s way to achieve a mission objective, it is incumbent upon commanders to avoid exposing them to unnecessary risk. The Army owes these soldiers and their families a clear-eyed assessment of what went wrong, why force protection warnings and intelligence assessments were disregarded, and why soldiers whose critical work reportedly required them to be within range of Iranian attacks were not adequately prepared or protected.

What We’re Reading:

“Trump’s War on Data Access Has Taken to the Stars” by Mary Guenther and Danielle Steitz in Radically Pragmatic

In a recently published op-ed, PPI’s Head of Space Policy Mary Guenther and Director of National Security Policy Danielle Steitz highlight the Trump administration’s clampdown on commercial remote sensing data over the Middle East, a move that restricts Americans’ access to truth and places ad hoc and indefinite restrictions on the remote sensing data industry. Guenther and Steitz argue that Congress’s attempt to establish a formalized process for these restrictions through the Intelligence Authorization Act is a step in the right direction, but striking the right balance between national security and access to data is critical and requires voices in addition to the national security establishment at the table.

Guenther and Steitz on Radically Pragmatic: Trump’s War on Data Access Has Taken to the Stars

President Donald Trump’s war on facts has reached the final frontier. Having already undermined federal data sources on everything from hunger to weather for its own self-interested ends, the administration has spent much of this year trying to squelch information about the Iran War by clamping down on the public’s access to data and images shot from space.

Congress looks ready to respond to this blatant censorship effort as part of an upcoming intelligence bill. But while it’s encouraging that lawmakers want to curb this administration’s abuses of power, the solution they are contemplating allows defense and intelligence agencies, organizations with cultures of information sharing on a “need-to-know” basis, to further clamp down on data availability — albeit for less politically charged reasons — without having anyone at the table arguing for the benefits of public access.

Back in March, the government reportedly asked commercial remote sensing companies like Planet Labs to delay release of the data and pictures they gather from space of much of the Middle East, in light of the Iran War. At the time, embarrassing photos of burning oil infrastructure and damaged American bases running in the press had undercut White House claims to have defeated Tehran’s military. The request was framed as voluntary, but as one geospatial analyst put it: “When your largest customer is also the government that regulates you, the line between voluntary and involuntary gets very thin.”

These restrictions were originally slated to last two weeks. Instead, they have lingered for the better part of six months, limiting information about the region to the subset of customers who comply with the companies’ restrictive managed access policies. Publications like the New York Times and The Washington Post, which frequently purchase images for their reporting, have used them to identify evidence of potential war crimes. Their access has been turned off indefinitely.

All of this has deprived everyday Americans of crucial news on the conflict — much to the alarm of some soldiers sent to fight it. Just last month, active service members anonymously sent photos to the press of the destruction of American bases out of concern that, in their words, “this is major damage to our bases that hasn’t been communicated to the American public…we’re standing there with our eyes closed getting punched in the face.”

Read more on Radically Pragmatic.

U.S. Military Completes Withdrawal from Iraq

By Danielle Steitz

Lately, it seems like every day begins with a torrent of headlines from an increasingly complex and rapidly changing global landscape. Wars in Europe and the Middle East prompt fears of escalation and geopolitical confrontation, while proliferating technologies like artificial intelligence threaten to reshape the security landscape. Political, security, economic, and technological concerns are increasingly intertwined, making the global landscape fraught with tensions and trade-offs. And in the United States, the erratic and unprincipled leadership of the Trump administration is confounding America’s allies while emboldening her adversaries, creating a more unpredictable and dangerous world.

PPI seeks to offer a path for navigating this increasingly chaotic global environment through understanding the domains in which we operate, which is why we are proud to announce the launch of Domain Awareness. While there are countless stories each day that demand attention, PPI’s new weekly digest offers a curated list of the top stories that policymakers and practitioners need to read, paired with commentary from PPI’s policy experts. We hope you will join us each week as we seek to understand current events and trends, and as we offer pragmatic policy solutions towards a more stable and secure future.

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

U.S. Military Completes Withdrawal from Iraq

By Danielle Steitz

On Wednesday, the U.S. military formally withdrew from Iraq, bringing two decades of U.S. military presence to a close. The departure of the final 2,500 Americans stationed in Erbil marks the end of Operation Inherent Resolve in Iraq, which brought American forces back to the country in 2014 as part of a multinational military campaign against jihadist Islamic State forces. The departure of the American military contingent from Iraq marks a milestone moment, with Iraqis commemorating the withdrawal with a three-day “celebration of sovereignty” while expressing complicated feelings about the legacy of American military presence and concern over Iraq’s future in the face of growing threats from Iranian-backed militia groups operating in the country.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: Iraq is again solely responsible for its own security, leading some Iraqi citizens to question what will be different this time than in 2011, when American withdrawal and weak Iraqi governance opened the door for the rapid spread of ISIS. While Combined Joint Task Force-Operation Inherent Resolve will continue its counter-ISIS mission from its relocated headquarters in Jordan, the Iraqi government must now rein in increasingly powerful militia groups that Iran views as key partners in its conflict with the U.S. and America’s Middle East allies. The U.S. withdrawal was negotiated by the Biden administration in 2024 and therefore predates the Trump administration’s war with Iran, but when paired with an ongoing review of U.S. presence in the Middle East in light of the conflict, it reflects a bipartisan desire to move past the legacy of the “forever wars” of Iraq and Afghanistan.

Iran War Diplomatic Efforts and Domestic Politics

by Danielle Steitz

As the Iran War stretches into its seventh month, efforts to find a diplomatic resolution to the conflict continue, but with little to show for it. Qatari shuttle diplomacy and indirect talks on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly between U.S. and Iranian negotiators led to an Iranian proposal that reportedly called for restarting nuclear talks and reopening the Strait of Hormuz after the U.S. lifts both its naval blockade and its oil sanctions and reinstates a region-wide ceasefire. President Trump rejected this proposal and acknowledged that he may resume strikes against Iran – much to the dismay of Republican candidates in tightly contested elections, who are increasingly calling for the war to end quickly. 

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: Both the Trump administration and the Iranian regime seem to believe that time is on their side, and that dragging out the conflict to maximally inflict economic and political damage on the other is their best path to victory — effectively turning the conflict into a waiting game to see who blinks first. But with polling data continually showing overwhelming American disapproval of the war and gas prices spiking to a new highest recorded average diesel price, members of the president’s party are increasingly concerned that the war will prove to be a drag on their electoral chances in a midterm election that is poised to be a referendum on the president’s performance. With the economy and affordability continuing to be a chief concern for Americans and control of both the House and Senate in the balance, the pressure to bring the war to an end appears to be mounting — but thus far, it has yet to sway Trump from his “inflict economic pressure and wait it out” approach. 

Starship Test Launch and Space Implications

by Mary Guenther

The next-generation launch vehicle from SpaceX successfully completed its first orbital test flight this week. This Starship vehicle will be dramatically more capable than SpaceX’ current workhorse, the Falcon class of vehicles, allowing for each launch to deploy 20 times more Starlink broadband satellites. SpaceX launches the majority of government payloads for civil and national security agencies alike, and NASA is reliant on Starship for its Artemis program. 

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Mary Guenther, Head of Space Policy: The Department of Defense currently uses the Falcon class of vehicles for most of its national security launches through the National Security Space Launch (NSSL) program. SpaceX plans to phase out the Falcon class of vehicles after it completes the missions it’s currently on contract for to allow the company to focus on Starship. The Starship will be a transformational capability for the American space program, opening possibilities for crewed and cargo missions that nothing on the market can offer today. A number of companies’ spacecraft and scientific missions in process today are only feasible because of the Starship. However, there are questions about whether there could be a gap between the Falcon 9 and the Starship, which would exacerbate launch capacity constraints for companies looking to fly their spacecraft.

Retired Spy Satellite Unexpectedly Blew Up in Orbit

by Mary Guenther

A satellite launched by the National Reconnaissance Office (NRO) in 1988 shattered in orbit this week, generating a large debris field of space trash that will make it harder to use the popular orbit it was flying in. The orbit is home to over 200 satellites, including aging NOAA weather satellites. The satellite’s mission was to find and listen to Soviet radar systems, though given that the project was fully declassified earlier this year, it’s safe to assume it was retired sometime in the past several decades. It’s unclear whether the breakup of the satellite was caused by an old component rupturing or if it was hit by a small piece of debris.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Mary Guenther, Head of Space Policy: This is the kind of incident the space community has been concerned about for some time. There are a host of old (primarily) U.S. and Soviet spacecraft and rocket bodies left in orbit that are vulnerable to this kind of event. Modern licensing processes require that satellites deorbit no later than five years after the end of their mission to avoid a build-up of space junk. And there are new companies exploring technologies that would help old or disabled spacecraft deorbit, though it’s unclear at this time whether governments will be interested in contracting them to clean up old satellites from the Cold War era. This incident may spur further thinking in that direction.

Navy Announces Contract for F/A-XX Sixth-Generation Fighter

by Danielle Steitz

The Navy announced this week that it has awarded the contract for its sixth-generation F/A-XX fighter jet to Boeing, a key next step in getting the next generation of fighters into service as a replacement for the F/A-18 Super Hornet and EA-18G Growler airframes. The award had reportedly been delayed for over a year by a fight that saw the White House and Pentagon advocating for delay of the award and reductions to the program’s budget while the U.S. Navy and Congress pressed for rapid fielding of the fighter given its centrality to naval aviation in a potential conflict with China. 

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: It is heartening to see the F/A-XX fighter program overcome the bureaucratic obstacles that had long delayed this contract award. While uncrewed systems like the Collaborative Combat Aircraft will provide a force multiplier to aviators in future conflicts, effective combat deployment of these systems still requires a next-generation strike fighter to “quarterback” and manage the battlespace. This contract being awarded without further delay will help to keep downstream aviation industrial base suppliers engaged and working — ideally without any further disruption or delay in producing and deploying these critical aircraft.

What We’re Reading:

“America’s Next Military Advantage is Trusted Data” by Jeremy Bayer in RealClearDefense

This article clearly identifies the next challenge to tackle in the age of information-integrated military operations: how to ensure data remains protected and verifiable while still enabling sharing and interoperability. American innovation is driving technology solutions forward, but the national security architecture must keep pace in adopting those solutions. 

Surviving Chaos: Geopolitics When the Rules Fail by Mark Leonard

In his new book, Leonard, the co-founder and director of the European Council on Foreign Relations, argues that the international liberal order is collapsing into what he describes as “Un-Order” — a permanent state where there is no longer agreement on fundamental rules, facts, or even the concept of global governance. In navigating this new reality, Leonard argues for leaders to move away from trying to restore a dead system, and instead to adopt the mindset of “artisans,” who embrace improvisation and build resilience in order to weather constant disruption.

Introducing Domain Awareness

Introducing Domain Awareness: A new weekly feature from PPI’s national security team

By Danielle Steitz

Lately, it seems like every day begins with a torrent of headlines from an increasingly complex and rapidly changing global landscape. Wars in Europe and the Middle East prompt fears of escalation and geopolitical confrontation, while proliferating technologies like artificial intelligence threaten to reshape the security landscape. Political, security, economic, and technological concerns are increasingly intertwined, making the global landscape fraught with tensions and trade-offs. And in the United States, the erratic and unprincipled leadership of the Trump administration is confounding America’s allies while emboldening her adversaries, creating a more unpredictable and dangerous world.

PPI seeks to offer a path for navigating this increasingly chaotic global environment through understanding the domains in which we operate, which is why we are proud to announce the launch of Domain Awareness. While there are countless stories each day that demand attention, PPI’s new weekly digest offers a curated list of the top stories that policymakers and practitioners need to read, paired with commentary from PPI’s policy experts. We hope you will join us each week as we seek to understand current events and trends, and as we offer pragmatic policy solutions towards a more stable and secure future.

THIS WEEK’S
TOP STORIES

Europe’s warning lights are blinking red

By Danielle Steitz and Tamar Jacoby

Leaders throughout Europe have spent the past several days publicly stating that Russia has stepped up its hybrid activity targeted at their nations, and may continue to escalate in order to probe Europe’s response. French President Emmanuel Macron and Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk both addressed the increase in Russian malign activity, describing it as designed to degrade support for Ukraine and to drive a wedge between NATO allies. These warnings come amidst events like last month’s drone attack at Leipzig Airport, suspicious fires and sabotage operations targeting European defense facilities, and a drone attack on a train that narrowly missed former U.K. Prime Minister Boris Johnson and former U.S. CIA director David Petraeus.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: European leaders are reading recent Russian actions as forecasting the desire to continue probing Europe’s resolve, and are reacting to warn their publics and the world accordingly. Russia appears to perceive a divide between the U.S. and European NATO allies, and will take every opportunity it can to create distance and doubt in the alliance.

Tamar Jacoby, Kyiv-based director of the New Ukraine Project: Most of the world is still using the phrase “hybrid war” to describe Russia’s escalating aggression in Europe: sabotage, arson, assassination attempts, cable-cuttings, airspace violations, cyberattacks, and campaigns to undermine electoral integrity. But after four years and hundreds of incidents, some Europeans say it’s time to drop the word hybrid. “The reality is that Russia considers itself at war with Europe,” Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha explained this month, “even if Europe does not consider itself at war with Russia.”

One of Moscow’s goals is clearly to suppress Western support for Ukraine, persuading European voters that it’s in their interest to pursue peace at any price on Russia’s terms. But it’s hard to believe the motive ends there. The Kremlin has long framed its aggression in Europe as part of a conflict with “the collective West,” and Vladimir Putin makes no secret of his desire to reclaim the Cold War Soviet sphere of influence – a huge swath of what’s now free, democratic Europe, including one-third of Berlin. Europeans are increasingly alarmed but only beginning to grapple with the implications – what would it mean to be at war with Russia, for national governments and for NATO?

For additional PPI insight on this topic, please see “Europe Struggles to Respond to Russian Attacks” by Tamar Jacoby.

A new escalation between Russia and Ukraine

By Tamar Jacoby and Danielle Steitz

As Ukraine prepares for its fifth winter under Russian attack, the evolving conflict appears to have undergone yet another shift. This past weekend, Ukraine launched its largest strike yet into the Moscow region, reportedly using over 1,100 drones as well as Ukrainian-manufactured Flamingo and Pelican missiles to target infrastructure in the region that includes one of Russia’s largest oil refineries. At the same time, Russia has stepped up its use of jet-powered Geran drones to attack targets across Ukraine, increasing the reach of the conflict and eliminating any sense of distance between civilians and the frontlines.

PPI Expert Assessment: 

Tamar Jacoby, Kyiv-based director of the New Ukraine Project: Everyone knew this would be a difficult fall in Ukraine. Ukrainian long-range drones and missiles have been pummeling Russia for months, striking at the heart of its economy by incapacitating 45 percent of its oil refining capacity – and everyone knew a wounded Putin would be an even more dangerous Putin.

Now, Moscow is striking back, and it has some nasty new weapons to do it with, including North Korean ballistic missiles and drones equipped with Chinese jet engines. Ukraine will soon have an answer for the jet drones. Several prototypes have been tested and will now go into mass production.

 But only the West can help Kyiv down ballistic missiles. Congress should press Trump to allow Ukraine to produce its own Patriot interceptors. Trump should press America’s allies — including Spain and Greece — to give Kyiv the interceptors lying unused in their storerooms. Elon Musk should give Ukraine permission to use Starlink to strike ballistic-missile launch sites deep inside Russia. Then, the US should follow through on the sanctions and tariffs authorized by the Lindsey Graham bill. Ukraine is heading into a tough winter – probably the toughest of the war. All its friends and allies need to step up and help.

Danielle Steitz, Director of National Security Policy: The Russia-Ukraine war has seen rapid technological iteration and tactical adaptation, and this current moment is no exception. Ukraine’s Operation Vivaldi, where heavy drones were used to deploy kamikaze ground drones behind Russian lines, demonstrates Ukrainian ingenuity and has reportedly disrupted Russian ground advances in Donetsk. However, with very few options to shoot down Geran drones currently available, Ukraine faces increasing difficulties in replicating that operational success in the air domain — particularly when it comes to air defense.

For additional PPI insight on this topic, please see “The New Normal in Kyiv, Ukraine” by Tamar Jacoby.

Iran War costs increasing, with no end in sight

By Danielle Steitz

The Pentagon’s cost estimates for the ongoing conflict against Iran continue to increase, with the latest total at $45.1 billion as of September 3rd, per reporting from CNN. This number includes operations costs and the increased cost of fuel, but does not include potential reconstruction costs for damaged U.S. military bases in the region. A recent CBO report assessed that costs for the war could increase at the rate of $2-3 billion per month, depending on the intensity of the conflict and operational demand.

PPI Expert Assessment: Despite the Trump administration’s assertions to the contrary, the war with Iran persists. The war, which looks far more like a regional conflict given the recent success of the Iranian-aligned Houthis in capturing control of the Bab al-Mandeb Strait, continues to cost the U.S. billions of dollars in operational and maintenance costs alone. Although Trump seeks to project confidence in promising that the war will end “immediately after” the midterm elections in November, Iran’s leaders seem to believe they can increase direct and indirect war costs enough to undermine America’s will and drive Trump to the bargaining table.

Military intelligence vs. artificial intelligence

By Danielle Steitz

As the national debate around AI safety and responsible pacing of frontier models grows louder, a recent CNN report demonstrates that no matter how advanced the model, human review and verification of outputs remain incredibly necessary. A U.S. military intelligence analyst utilized a Department of Defense-approved AI chatbot to draft an intelligence assessment on a Chinese ship, only for the U.S. military to reportedly realize at the last minute that the AI had misidentified the ship’s cargo as nuclear components – a “hallucination” that nearly sparked a war.

PPI Expert Assessment: As Secretary of Defense, Pete Hegseth has pushed for the rapid and full-throated embrace of AI systems throughout all DoD processes and use cases, advocating for speed over everything else. As stated in his January 2026 Artificial Intelligence Acceleration Strategy, “We must accept that the risks of not moving fast enough outweigh the risks of imperfect alignment.” If Secretary Hegseth truly views the potential of the American military hallucinating itself into a conflict with China as an acceptable risk of “imperfect alignment,” that irresponsible and cavalier attitude is exactly the wrong one to be leading the Department of Defense at this high-stakes global moment.

Jacoby Joins Joan Esposito on WCPT

Joan Esposito is joined by Tamar Jacoby, director of the New Ukraine Project at the Progressive Policy Institute and contributor to Washington Monthly; her latest articles are “The New Normal in Kyiv, Ukraine” and “Europe Struggles to Respond to Russian Attacks.” The discussion examined Russia’s escalating hybrid war in Europe and the implications for Ukraine, NATO, and Western deterrence. Here are a few key points from the conversation:

  • Jacoby described roughly 400 to 450 suspected Russian attacks in Europe over four years, including sabotage, arson, cyberattacks, drone activity, and attempted assassinations.
  • European governments are improving information sharing, monitoring, patrols, and defensive infrastructure, but largely avoid retaliation.
  • Russia is making limited progress on the front but has intensified its air campaign with faster, higher-flying drones and attacks on Ukraine’s power, water, and sewage systems.
  • Ukraine has damaged approximately 45 percent of Russia’s oil-refining capacity, while Russia continues receiving support, including drone engines, from China.

Steitz for MS Now: Trump’s New Defense for His Arch Is Absurd – And Dangerous

Let’s be clear: No matter what President Donald Trump may say, the national security of the United States does not require the construction of a massive arch in the middle of a traffic circle.

In a saner world, this would not need to be said. But on Friday, the president announced a new purpose for the 250-foot-tall tourist attraction he is seeking to build in the roundabout at the end of Washington’s Memorial Bridge. The arch will double as a “military complex,” Trump said, housing drones and ammo while providing a platform for snipers.

What possible threat aimed at Arlington National Cemetery — of all places — requires the construction of a marble-and-gold arch?

Throughout his second term, Trump has repeatedly invoked flimsy national security excuses to justify policy priorities both big and small. The arch might be the most ludicrous example yet: By claiming that this obvious vanity project is in fact a top Pentagon priority, the administration is clearly hoping it can convince U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan to reconsider her injunction pausing its construction.

My guess is that the argument will get laughed out of court. But that leaves a bigger issue: Judges have long given presidents vast leeway when it comes to national security decisions. Trump’s obvious abuse of that privilege has started forcing them to rethink that stance, which could make it harder to deal with a real emergency in the future.

Read more in MS Now.